Commentary by Terri LaPoint
Well being Impression Information
There are parts which might be widespread virtually to the level of being common in instances involving youngsters taken from their households by Youngster Protecting Providers, together with false allegations, mendacity by social staff, falsified medical data, failure of social staff to comply with their very own insurance policies, legal guidelines damaged by CPS, and the failure to contemplate proof that refutes CPS allegations.
Nevertheless, there’s one factor that is still uncommon in CPS instances – that’s, for anybody inside the system to be held accountable. Repercussions for social staff, the CPS company, or docs concerned in taking youngsters from harmless mother and father are very uncommon.
On Thursday, November eight, 2018, a decide in Houston, Texas, referred to as CPS on the carpet, issuing what the Houston Chronicle says:
…could also be the largest-ever sanctions towards Baby Protecting Providers, forcing the state to provide you with new coaching for its staff and pay greater than $127,000 for wrongfully eradicating a pair’s youngsters and allegedly mendacity to the courtroom about it.
This follows a choice that Judge Mike Schneider issued final month involving mother and father Melissa and Dillon Brilliant, the similar household whose youngsters have been medically kidnapped by CPS and Texas Children’s Hospital.
- 0.1 In Unprecedented Transfer Texas Judge Orders CPS to Have No Contact with 2 Children Eliminated with out Warrant – Social Employee Pleads fifth in Court
- 1 Unqualified Social Employee
- 2 Lies by Social Staff Are Not Acceptable
- 3 CPS Has Immunity, or Do They?
- 4 Judge Slaps CPS with High quality, Orders New Coaching for Staff
- 5 No Penalties for Baby Abuse Docs at Texas Children’s Hospital
- 6 Medical Kidnapping: A Menace to Each Household in America T-Shirt
- 7 Medical Kidnapping is REAL!
In Unprecedented Transfer Texas Judge Orders CPS to Have No Contact with 2 Children Eliminated with out Warrant – Social Employee Pleads fifth in Court
Houston Chronicle reporter Keri Blakinger writes:
It’s an uncommon case that gives repeated examples of CPS missteps, however the Brights’ attorneys say it’s additionally an indication of a “broken system” and the want for extra accountability from the company tasked with making selections as to whether or not mother and father are match to maintain their very own youngsters.
Whereas we might agree that extra accountability is definitely wanted, we at Well being Influence Information have discovered after years of in-depth investigation of a whole lot of comparable instances that the Vibrant household case is something however “an unusual case.” On the opposite, their story is typical of what we see regularly.
The small print of the story are in the Houston Chronicle piece. The essence of the story is that this:
There was an unintentional damage when their 5-month-old child fell off of a chair. Melissa Vibrant referred to as 911, and the child was taken to Texas Children’s Hospital.
Like most youngsters’s hospitals, Texas Children’s has a Baby Abuse group. They deemed the child’s accidents to be “consistent with child abuse,” which finally led to CPS seizing custody of the Brights’ two youngsters.
The youngsters have been taken and not using a warrant in an “emergency removal,” and the social employee lied in his reviews to the courtroom about the details of the state of affairs.
Different docs found that the child had an underlying medical situation, a blood-clotting dysfunction, however that info was ignored by CPS.
The mother and father weren’t informed about the emergency removing listening to or given any alternative to defend themselves when their youngsters have been taken.
Once more, there’s nothing on this account that’s any totally different from some other story that we have now coated over a number of years.
The distinction lies in the conclusions by Judge Mike Schneider, who’s to be recommended for standing up for what is true, in each final month’s listening to and yesterday’s listening to.
“It is not possible,” Schneider stated in courtroom final month, “to look at the facts and imagine that the agency actually felt there was any sort of urgent need for protection to remove the children.” (Supply).
Attorneys for the Brights requested, and received, sanctions positioned on the CPS division for their blatant failures in medically kidnapping youngsters from harmless mother and father.
In the sanctions listening to which concluded yesterday, attorneys Dennis Slate and Stephanie Proffitt:
…argued that the company’s efforts to take the youngsters have been based mostly on such groundless arguments that they need to be pressured to pay the household for authorized charges and different prices – a complete of greater than $127,000.
Now, attorneys for mother and father Melissa and Dillon Shiny are calling for the firing of the CPS staff concerned and asking for prosecutors to examine and think about legal fees.
Unqualified Social Employee
The Houston Chronicle stories:
Over the course of 5 days, the courtroom heard testimony from the Brights, a program director and supervisor Edwards who drew incredulous seems to be in the courtroom when she so incessantly claimed that she didn’t know, couldn’t reply or didn’t perceive the questions that Slate ultimately requested whether or not she had any information that made her certified to make selections.
Lies by Social Staff Are Not Acceptable
The household’s attorneys introduced proof that the social staff lied repeatedly to the courtroom:
“They lied in their affidavit, they lied in their sworn removal testimony and they have – when questioned about those lies – taken the Fifth,” stated household lawyer Dennis Slate.
“When the Harris County District Attorney [Kim Ogg] ran for office said that she would investigate perjury claims within the Harris County courts. She needs to live up to that campaign promise and look into this case and bring the appropriate action.”
Observe: DA Kim Ogg could also be reached at 713-274-5800. Her workplace can also be on Twitter right here.
In October 1016, Youngster Protecting Providers attorneys in Orange County California tried to argue to the ninth Circuit of Appeals that it was acceptable for social staff to lie about mother and father so as to take their youngsters. Like Harris County Texas decide Mike Schneider, the ninth Circuit judicial panel didn’t purchase that logic both.
Judges Reject Declare That Social Staff Didn’t Know Lying In Court to Take away Children Was Flawed
CPS Has Immunity, or Do They?
The Houston Chronicle continues:
Stephen Dieu with the Harris County Lawyer’s Workplace, which represented CPS in the listening to … argued repeatedly that the company was protected by sovereign immunity.
“There are legal remedies but this is not the one,” he stated. “The department cannot be sanctioned.”
However a glance again at company data would present that’s not true.
Seven years in the past, Slate and Proffitt gained a $32,000 sanction in one other case involving a “groundless” removing the place the company didn’t inform the mother and father about the emergency listening to and waited hours to take the youngsters after courts closed.
“When we got the sanctions in 2011, we really thought that would open somebody’s eyes,” Proffitt stated. “There are only a handful of cases in Harris County that have even filed for sanctions. There’s no repercussions.”
This time, there have been. [Emphasis added by HIN].
Judge Slaps CPS with High quality, Orders New Coaching for Staff
The Houston Chronicle states:
In a scathing ruling from the bench on Thursday, Schneider dinged the company for being “dishonest” and probably “malicious,” saying the whole removing and subsequent authorized battle by no means would have occurred if the company simply informed the Brights about the emergency removing listening to and gave them an opportunity to defend themselves at the begin.
“We do need to deal with the issue of how we make sure this doesn’t happen again,” he stated, earlier than ordering the company to pay $127,000 and giving them two weeks to create new coaching for its staff.
However, Schneider stated, there was one factor the household requested that he couldn’t order: an apology.
No Penalties for Baby Abuse Docs at Texas Children’s Hospital
For the Brilliant household, these sanctions of CPS are welcome information. Nevertheless, there isn’t a point out of any repercussions for Texas Children’s Hospital or the Youngster Abuse staff of pediatricians that obtained the ball rolling to take the Vibrant youngsters from their house.
The position of Baby Abuse Pediatricians in these instances can’t be understated. CPS social staff will not be docs, and thus aren’t in a position to do the wanted differential diagnoses to decide whether or not or not a toddler was abused or if they’ve an actual medical situation that mimics abuse. They typically merely take the phrase of the baby abuse docs with out query. Attorneys and judges in flip typically don’t query these docs.
Thus, a lot of the blame for medical kidnapping of youngsters from harmless mother and father lies squarely at the ft of those docs, who are usually not specialists in something.
Pediatric Youngster Abuse “Experts” are NOT Specialists in Something
The top of the Texas Children’s Hospital Baby Abuse staff is Christopher Spencer Greeley, MD. He did his internship at Vanderbilt College, one other hospital recognized for its position in lots of medical kidnap instances.
Dr. Greeley is a serious participant in the subject of Baby Abuse Pediatrics and is at present the president of the Ray E. Helfer Society, the Worldwide Society for Physicians in the Area of Baby Abuse.
We first reported on the Helfer Society earlier this yr. One other of their members, Dr. Carole Jenny, coauthored a ebook together with her psychiatrist husband Dr. Thomas A. Roesler entitled, Medical Baby Abuse: Past Munchausen by Proxy, which redefines Munchausen Syndrome by Proxy so as to make it attainable to cost extra mother and father. We reported:
Dr. Jenny is a part of the Helfer Society – an elite group of docs concerned with Baby Abuse. She gained the Helfer Society’s Award in 2004. Per their web site:
The Helfer Award is given yearly to the member of the Society who has made vital contributions to the subject of Baby Abuse Pediatrics.
The listing of recipients accommodates a number of names which have come up repeatedly in our analysis of Medical Kidnap articles. It appears that evidently a small group of individuals have acquired a substantial amount of energy over the lives of American households as they influence coverage, philosophy, and judicial selections. See the listing right here.
California Christian Homeschool Household Torn Aside as Children are Medically Kidnapped, Pressured into Public Faculty, and Mom is Pressured out of Household House
The Brights are grateful for the sanctions towards CPS.
Nevertheless, the Youngster Abuse Pediatric Workforce at Texas Children’s Hospital has not been confronted with any penalties for their position in the Vibrant youngsters being taken.
Touch upon this text at MedicalKidnap.com.
Medical Kidnapping: A Menace to Each Household in America T-Shirt
100% Pre-shrunk Cotton!
Order right here!
Medical Kidnapping is REAL!
See: Medical Kidnapping: A Menace to Each Household in America At present
Assist unfold the consciousness of Medical Kidnapping by sporting the Medical Kidnapping t-shirt!
Help the explanation for MedicalKidnap.com, which is a part of the Well being Impression Information community.
Order right here!
If you recognize people who find themselves skeptical and can’t consider that medical kidnapping occurs in the U.S. in the present day, that is the e-book for them! Backed with strong references and actual life examples, they will be unable to deny the plain proof earlier than them, and will develop into higher educated on this matter that’s destroying the American household.
1 E-book – 228 pages
FREE Delivery Obtainable!
Order right here!
Retail: $49.98 (for 2 books)
FREE Delivery Out there!
Now: $19.99 (for 2 books)
Order right here!
Additionally obtainable as eBook:
eBook – Obtain Instantly!
Revealed on November 9, 2018